CO129-215 - Governor Sir Bowen - 1884 [1-4] — Page 631

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

628

but, as Bishop Raimondi seems to think the Roman Catholic Church does not get fairly paid for the use of its buildings, this consideration might perhaps be waived. It is difficult to see, however, in the case of either the Anglican or Roman Catholic Churches, why the Colony should pay for their use by the Troops.

As to the claim of $6,000 for past services in the Gaol and Hospital, I do not think it can be entertained. When any person or association is performing gratuitous work for the Government, it is quite open to that person to claim reasonable payment or to discontinue the services. But the Government would never be safe if the principle of allowing claims for arrears were once conceded.

Claims for gratuitous services rendered in the past might only have been accepted because they were gratuitous, and thirty or forty years afterwards, it would be difficult to decide on their value. It would be very embarrassing, for instance, were Dr. Legge suddenly to bring forward a heavy claim for his most valuable assistance to the Government, as its Chinese referee, during many years when there was no one else in the Colony to turn to.

But I am bound to point out that this claim for $6,000 would seem to be only a change of front about another matter. In a previous correspondence, Bishop Raimondi urged that he should have a much larger...

Edit History

2026-05-24 10:22:52 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
628 but, as Bishop Raimondi seems to think the Roman Catholic Church does not get fairly paid for the use of its buildings, this consideration might perhaps be waived. It is difficult to see, however, in the case of either the Anglican or Roman Catholic Churches, why the Colony should pay for their use by the Troops. As to the claim of $6,000 for past services in the Gaol and Hospital, I do not think it can be entertained. When any person or association is performing gratuitous work for the Government, it is quite open to that person to claim reasonable payment or to discontinue the services. But the Government would never be safe if the principle of allowing claims for arrears were once conceded. Claims for gratuitous services rendered in the past might only have been accepted because they were gratuitous, and thirty or forty years afterwards, it would be difficult to decide on their value. It would be very embarrassing, for instance, were Dr. Legge suddenly to bring forward a heavy claim for his most valuable assistance to the Government, as its Chinese referee, during many years when there was no one else in the Colony to turn to. But I am bound to point out that this claim for $6,000 would seem to be only a change of front about another matter. In a previous correspondence, Bishop Raimondi urged that he should have a much larger...
Baseline (Original)
628 but, as Bishop Raimondi seems to think the Roman Catholic Church does not, 4 get m fairly paid for the use of its buildings, this "consideration might perhaps be waived. It is difficult to see, however, in the cace of either the Anglican or Roman Catholic Churches, why the Colony should pay for their use by the Troops As to the claim of $6.000 for past services in the Gurol and Hospital, I do not think it can be entertained. When any person or association is ~u~ performing gratuitous work for the Government, it is quite open to that person to clains reasonable payment or to discontinue the services. But the Government would rever be safe if the principle of allowing claims for arrears were once conceded. of ofservice in the past. Such gratitus . cepted. services might only have bow ace, because they were gratuitous, and thirty or forty years afterwards, it would be difficult to decide on their valice = would be It very embarrassing, for. instance, were D. # Legge suddenly to bring forward a heavy claim for his most valuable assistance to the Government. as its Chinese referee. during many years when there was no one else in the Colony to turn to: But I am bound to point out that this claim for $6,000 would seem to be only a change offrout about another matter. In a previous. Correspondence Bishop Raimondi - urged that he should have a much larger
2026-05-24 10:22:52 · Baseline
View content

628

but, as Bishop Raimondi seems to think the

Roman Catholic Church does not,

4 get m fairly paid for the use of its buildings, this "consideration might perhaps be waived. It is difficult to see, however, in the cace of either the Anglican or Roman Catholic Churches, why the Colony should pay for their use by the Troops As to the claim of $6.000 for past services in the Gurol and Hospital, I do not think it can be entertained. When

any person or association is ~u~ performing gratuitous work for the Government, it is quite open to that person to clains reasonable payment or to discontinue the services. But the Government would rever be safe if the principle of allowing claims for arrears

were once conceded.

of

ofservice in the past. Such gratitus

.

cepted.

services might only have bow ace, because they were gratuitous, and thirty

or

forty years afterwards, it would be difficult to decide on their valice =

would be

It

very embarrassing, for. instance, were D. # Legge suddenly to bring forward a heavy claim for his

most valuable assistance to the

Government. as its Chinese referee.

during many years

when there was

no one else in the Colony to turn to:

But I am bound to point out that this claim for $6,000 would seem

to be only a change offrout about another matter. In a previous. Correspondence Bishop Raimondi - urged that he should have a much

larger

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.